A rare Conesus Lake opportunity.
Waterfront living today with room to dream about tomorrow. This beautifully rebuilt year-round lake home offers 1,128 sq. ft. of living area per the current MLS/assessor record, approximately 0.28 acres per the current MLS spanning both sides of East Lake Road, 56.23 feet of private Conesus Lake frontage based on the 2020 survey tie-line measurement, spectacular sunsets, an approximately 60-foot dock, and additional land across the road. All on one tax parcel.
More than a lake house.
A rebuilt waterfront home, substantial private lake frontage, a long dock, an upper deck overlooking the water, additional land across the road, and a compelling long-term vision make this property unusually flexible.
Live here now. Build for tomorrow.
Enjoy the waterfront home today, preserve its potential rental flexibility subject to applicable laws and regulations, and pursue a larger primary residence across the road subject to applicable Town requirements and approvals.
Bright, airy and designed around the lake.
Extensively rebuilt around 2019 with a new roof, siding, windows and more, the home was designed to take full advantage of its waterfront setting.
Inside, soaring vaulted ceilings, an open-concept layout and abundant natural light create an inviting space where the lake is never far from view. The home features one private bedroom plus a spacious open loft/sleeping area and two full bathrooms.
Both the bedroom and loft have their own sliding glass doors opening directly onto the second-story deck overlooking the lake, creating a memorable setting for morning coffee, quiet afternoons or unforgettable sunsets.
Year-round comforts include radiant-floor heat, gas stove, laundry, ceiling fans, portable air conditioning, exterior natural-gas hookup, and outdoor hot and cold water.
Rebuilt for year-round use
Major work around 2019 included roof, siding, windows and more.
Upper lake-view deck
Both the private bedroom and open loft connect directly to the second-story deck.
Comfort in every season
Radiant-floor heat and practical lake-house systems support year-round living.
Sunsets come standard.
56.23 feet of private Conesus Lake frontage based on the 2020 survey tie-line measurement, a breakwall and an approximately 60-foot dock put boating, swimming, fishing and kayaking right at your doorstep.
And every July 3rd, experience one of the lake's most beloved traditions: the annual Ring of Fire, when the shoreline comes alive with flares, fireworks and celebrations around the lake.
Create the next chapter of the property.
Across the road, the property continues with a spacious grassy area, mature trees, two existing outbuildings/storage structures, a gravel drive and parking for approximately four vehicles.
The additional land is one of the property's greatest assets and perhaps its most exciting opportunity. It creates an opportunity to pursue a larger primary residence while retaining the existing waterfront home, subject to applicable Town requirements and approvals.
Imagine building the home you have always wanted just across the road while preserving the lakefront cottage at the water's edge, a place for guests, quiet weekends, or potential continued rental use, subject to applicable laws and regulations.
Few properties offer that kind of flexibility: the potential for two distinct living spaces, one Conesus Lake setting, and the freedom to create a property with lasting flexibility.
Any future development is subject to applicable zoning, setbacks, municipal approvals and permitting. Future rental use is subject to applicable laws and regulations.
Helpful FEMA information is already in hand.
A FEMA Letter of Map Amendment is on file for the existing cottage/residence and shed, providing useful clarity about the existing improvements.
The FEMA Letter of Map Amendment confirms that the existing cottage/residence and shed have been removed from the Special Flood Hazard Area and are shown in Zone X, unshaded. Portions of the parcel remain within the Special Flood Hazard Area, and buyers should independently verify current FEMA mapping, flood insurance requirements and the applicability of floodplain regulations to any proposed future construction.
The lake, the light, the possibility.
From quiet mornings on the water to golden-hour sunsets, this is a property shaped by the Conesus Lake experience.
Waterfront. Sunsets. Additional land. Vision.
A beautifully rebuilt home, an established short-term rental history, future-building potential, and a Conesus Lake setting that is difficult to duplicate.
The public listing PDF reflects selected public listing information current as of October 1, 2026. For current status, price, availability and updates, use the live Realmart listing.